EnglishEN|USD
Home / Guides / Chianti or Montalcino

Chianti or Montalcino?

Chianti Classico is half an hour from Florence. Brunello and Vino Nobile are nearly two hours. Here is what each wine is, and what each day really costs you in time.

Hilltop Montalcino with its fortress above the vineyards
Montalcino, home of Brunello, 40 km south of Siena.

Booking choice: The Brunello day, from $81 per person. Check dates Tour details

The two big names in Tuscan red are both Sangiovese, and they could hardly make more different day trips. Chianti Classico starts where the Florence suburbs end. Brunello di Montalcino comes from a single hill town 116 km south, and Vino Nobile from Montepulciano, further east.

For a first wine day from Florence, we'd pick Chianti. For a wine lover who has already done Chianti, or who wants to see the Val d'Orcia anyway, the Brunello day is worth the long ride. Here is how to choose.

The quick answer

Pick Chianti Classico for a relaxed half day with more wine: the minibus tour pours 6 wines at two estates in 4.5 hours. Pick Montalcino for Brunello, Vino Nobile and the Val d'Orcia towns: an 11.5-hour coach day with two tastings, from $81. Staying in Siena or Rome changes the maths.

A long barrel cellar under stone vaults at a Montalcino winery
A Brunello cellar in Montalcino: at least two years in wood before release.

What is the difference between Chianti Classico and Brunello?

Both are Sangiovese. Brunello is 100% Sangiovese from Montalcino only, released five years after harvest. Chianti Classico needs at least 80% Sangiovese and can be released after a year.

Chianti ClassicoBrunello di MontalcinoVino Nobile di Montepulciano
GrapeMin. 80% Sangiovese100% SangioveseMin. 70% Sangiovese (Prugnolo Gentile)
Where71,800 ha between Florence and SienaMontalcino municipality onlyMontepulciano
Ageing12 months; Riserva 24; Gran Selezione 30Released in the 5th year, 2 years in wood2 years, at least 1 in oak; Riserva 3
From Florence20 to 40 minutes116 km, about 1 h 50Nearly 2 hours

In the glass, Chianti Classico tends to be fresher and brighter, with red cherry and acidity that loves food. Brunello is bigger, longer-aged and darker, and Rosso di Montalcino is the younger wine from the same zone. Both rules are set by their consortia: the Brunello consortium limits the wine to the Montalcino municipality, 24,000 hectares of which only 15% is vineyard.

Rolling Chianti hills with vineyards and woods
Chianti Classico: wooded hills, vineyards in patches, villages on the ridges.

How long is a Montalcino wine day from Florence?

11.5 to 12 hours on the coach tours, for two tastings. The Chianti minibus tour gives you three times the wine per hour.

Here is what each day costs in time, with the from-price:

DayHoursTastingsTownsFrom
Small-group Chianti tour4.52 estates, 6 winesNone$98
Full day in Chianti7.5 to 83 wineries + lunchGreve$164
Brunello and Vino Nobile day11.52 wineries + pecorinoMontalcino, Pienza, Montepulciano$81
Wine day from Rome11 to 121, with lunch, incl. BrunelloMontepulciano, Pienza$98

Nearly four of those hours on the Brunello day are on the coach. In return you see three hill towns and the Val d'Orcia, a UNESCO site since 2004. Guests who loved it say the pace works: "We visited the three cities at a fairly leisurely pace." Lunch is not included, so eat in the free time.

Val d'Orcia Day with Brunello & Vino Nobile

Brunello in Montalcino, Vino Nobile in Montepulciano and pecorino in Pienza: the long day south, by coach from Florence.

★ 4.7 · 11.5 hours · from $81

Explore the Brunello day Tour details

Which is better for a first wine tour, Chianti or Montalcino?

Chianti. It is closer, the tours pour more wine, and you are back in Florence by late afternoon with the evening free.

A first wine day should be about the cellar, the glass and the people who made it. Chianti Classico tours give you that with almost no road time, and the estates are used to explaining Sangiovese from scratch. You can taste Annata, Riserva and sometimes Gran Selezione side by side, which teaches you more about the grape than any single bottle.

Montalcino is the better day if the towns matter to you as much as the wine. Montalcino's fortress, Pienza's square and Montepulciano's cellars are a full sightseeing day with two tastings fitted in.

A first wine day done right: two Chianti estates, six wines, 4.5 hours, rated 4.9.

Check dates for the small-group Chianti tour

Is Vino Nobile the same as Montepulciano wine?

Vino Nobile di Montepulciano is a Tuscan Sangiovese named after the town. Montepulciano d'Abruzzo is a different grape from another region. They share only a name.

The mix-up catches people in wine shops at home. Vino Nobile is made around the hill town of Montepulciano, mainly from Sangiovese, which is called Prugnolo Gentile there. It became the first Italian wine with the DOCG neck strip, on 1 July 1980. Montepulciano d'Abruzzo is made from the Montepulciano grape on the Adriatic side of Italy.

On the Brunello day you taste both Brunello and Vino Nobile on one coach trip, which is the easiest way to compare them.

The hill town of Montepulciano with the church of San Biagio below
Montepulciano and the church of San Biagio, home of Vino Nobile.

What is the best red wine from Tuscany?

Brunello di Montalcino has the biggest reputation, Chianti Classico Gran Selezione is its match at the top of Chianti, and the Super Tuscans fetch the highest prices.

The honest answer is that the best Tuscan red is a Sangiovese, and you choose the style. Brunello is the long-aged, powerful one. Chianti Classico Riserva and Gran Selezione are the finest of the Classico hills: Gran Selezione is at least 90% Sangiovese from the estate's own grapes, aged 30 months. Vino Nobile sits between them. The Super Tuscans, often with Cabernet and Merlot, are a different story: see Super Tuscan wines explained.

The "big three" Italian reds people ask about are usually Barolo from Piedmont, Brunello and Chianti Classico. Two of them are in Tuscany.

Can I visit Montalcino from Siena or Rome instead?

From Siena, yes: Montalcino is only 40 km south. From Rome, the coach day to Montepulciano and Pienza is 11 to 12 hours and includes a Brunello tasting with lunch.

Staying in Siena moves the balance. Montalcino becomes a short drive, and so does Chianti, north of the city: the Chianti tour from Siena visits two wineries and Castellina in five hours by minivan.

From Rome, the wine day from Rome leaves Piazza del Popolo, spends 85 minutes in Montepulciano, serves a three-course farm lunch with a guided tasting that includes Brunello, then stops in Pienza. It is 2 hours 45 each way on the coach, so it suits people who want one Tuscan day in a Rome trip.

Red poppies in a field below the rolling Val d'Orcia hills
The Val d'Orcia between Montalcino and Pienza, on both the Florence and the Rome days.

Based in Rome: Montepulciano, Pienza and a farm lunch with Tuscan wines, there and back in a day.

Check dates for the wine day from Rome

What is the best wine region in Tuscany to visit?

For a day trip, Chianti Classico: close, beautiful and full of estates that welcome visitors. For a stay of several nights, Montalcino and the Val d'Orcia.

Chianti Classico wins on access. The villages of Greve, Panzano, Radda, Castellina and Gaiole are all within reach in a day, and many estates are set up for walk-in guests. Montalcino wins on drama and on the single wine. Bolgheri, on the coast, is the home of Sassicaia, but no standard tour from Florence goes there. San Gimignano, with its white Vernaccia, fits into a Chianti day on the minivan tour.

If you want both, split them: a Chianti half day early in the trip, and a night in Montalcino later. Our Chianti wineries guide covers which estates to aim for.

Frequently asked questions

Can you do Chianti and Montalcino in one day?

Not well. No standard tour from Florence combines them, and the drive between Greve and Montalcino alone is well over an hour. Do them on separate days.

Is Brunello stronger than Chianti?

Usually a little. Brunello is aged far longer and tends to be fuller, and Chianti Classico Riserva needs at least 12.5% alcohol against 12% for the basic Annata.

Does the Brunello day include lunch?

No. The coach day from Florence includes two winery tastings and Pienza pecorino, and you buy lunch in the free time. The Rome day includes a three-course lunch.

Is Montalcino worth it if I only have one day?

If you love Brunello or want the Val d'Orcia towns, yes. If you want the most wine and the least road, stay in Chianti.

Ready to book

Choose your tour

Free cancellation up to 24 hours before on every option. Prices are from-prices in USD and move with the season.

Val d'Orcia Day with Brunello & Vino Nobile

Val d'Orcia Day with Brunello & Vino Nobile

★ 4.7 · 11.5 hours

Brunello in Montalcino and Vino Nobile in Montepulciano, one long day

From$81per personCheck dates
Small-Group Chianti Wine Tasting Tour

Small-Group Chianti Wine Tasting Tour

★ 4.9 · 4.5 hours

  • Air-conditioned minibus from Piazzale Montelungo and back
  • Driver-guide all day
  • Guided visits to 2 wine estates in Chianti Classico
From$98per personCheck dates
Tuscany Wine Day from Rome with Lunch

Tuscany Wine Day from Rome with Lunch

★ 4.7 · 11 to 12 hours

Based in Rome: Montepulciano, Pienza and a farm lunch

From$98per personCheck dates

Plan your date before you go

Brunello in Montalcino, Vino Nobile in Montepulciano and pecorino in Pienza, in one long day from Florence.

Check dates for the Brunello day